All new trucks are junk these days?

testerdahl

testerdahl

Administrator
Staff member
I keep seeing comments like this come up whenever I post any recall story. It is almost getting to the point where I can literally count on it in the first 5 comments. Personally, I think he is wrong and, just to be clear, I don't take money.

IMO - the problem isn't that new trucks and SUVs are junk. It is more you hear about recalls and problems a LOT more often these days thanks to the internet. Also, NHTSA requires more recalls than they did in the past due to safety issues.

I also have owned several old trucks and I just don't see them as being more reliable, having better build quality and being superior to new trucks.

What do you think? How do you see it?


Screenshot 2024-09-13 at 12.27.42 PM.png
 
I think a lot of these junk complaints go away if they weren't gouging consumers on price every which way possible. The auto indsutry is ripe for another (mild) collapse. They're building vehicles nobody wants, EV, and raising the prices of the vehicles people do want, trucks and SUV's, to make up their losses.

It is going to catch up to them, it already is.
 
testerdahl said:
I keep seeing comments like this come up whenever I post any recall story. It is almost getting to the point where I can literally count on it in the first 5 comments. Personally, I think he is wrong and, just to be clear, I don't take money.

IMO - the problem isn't that new trucks and SUVs are junk. It is more you hear about recalls and problems a LOT more often these days thanks to the internet. Also, NHTSA requires more recalls than they did in the past due to safety issues.

I also have owned several old trucks and I just don't see them as being more reliable, having better build quality and being superior to new trucks.

What do you think? How do you see it?


View attachment 642
Click to expand...
I see this nonsense all the time. Is my 2023 GMC SIERRA 1500 better than my 1986 F250 and my 2003 SILVERADO 2500 HD? Yes, hands down is more comfortable, quieter, way more fuel efficient, safer and trouble free for almost 2 years. It puts a smile on my face every time I drive it. Would I have preferred it to be less expensive? Of course, but it’s payed for, so lets roll.
 
Fightnfire said:
I think a lot of these junk complaints go away if they weren't gouging consumers on price every which way possible. The auto indsutry is ripe for another (mild) collapse. They're building vehicles nobody wants, EV, and raising the prices of the vehicles people do want, trucks and SUV's, to make up their losses.

It is going to catch up to them, it already is.
Click to expand...
I think you’ll see dealerships wanting to make some deals especially RAM right now.
 
testerdahl said:
I keep seeing comments like this come up whenever I post any recall story. It is almost getting to the point where I can literally count on it in the first 5 comments. Personally, I think he is wrong and, just to be clear, I don't take money.

IMO - the problem isn't that new trucks and SUVs are junk. It is more you hear about recalls and problems a LOT more often these days thanks to the internet. Also, NHTSA requires more recalls than they did in the past due to safety issues.

I also have owned several old trucks and I just don't see them as being more reliable, having better build quality and being superior to new trucks.

What do you think? How do you see it?
Click to expand...

Calling everything junk is just a bit ridiculous. How does one even define junk? If he offered a halfway decent comparison, sure, maybe he could make an argument. I see more stories about how much better vehicles are all around today vice years ago. How we can put that many more miles on them, how much safer they are, how much more comfortable they are, and how much more performance we get out of them. Seems like the exact same story we heard 5 years ago, 10 years ago, etc.
 
My personal take is that average reliability for cars and trucks across all brands is much higher than it used to be. It’s notable that there are far fewer defects than there used to be while incorporating the EPA efficiency and US Govt safety mandates and consumer technology expectations. It’s really the latter of the three that are the cause of most consumer complaints. I‘ve experienced many systems across manufacturers and only a couple stand out as usable. Most are bloated because manufacturers thought they could save a dime on a button and made the airbox control 4 clicks deep in a screen.

Still, agree with others who’ve said modern vehicles are generally more comfortable, quieter, capable, and efficient than they were 25 years ago.
 
Last edited:
Rotten.dalton said:
My personal take is that average reliability for cars and trucks across all brands is much higher than it used to be. It’s notable that there are far fewer defects than there used to be while incorporating the EPA efficiency and US Govt mandates and consumer technology expectations. It’s really the latter of the three that are the cause of most consumer complaints. I‘ve experienced many systems across manufacturers and only a couple stand out as usable. Most are bloated because manufacturers thought they could save a dime on a button and made the airbox control 4 clicks deep in a screen.

Still, agree with others who’ve said modern vehicles are generally more comfortable, quieter, capable, and efficient than they were 25 years ago.
Click to expand...
That’s a well reasoned response. Would you like to reply to ALL the YouTube comments?? 😆
 
People made a lot of good points above, and yes I think it comes down to price.
When you're asking 80k for a work HD truck, 100K for a mid tier truck and 125K+ for premium, expectations change. When a base HD was 30k, it doesn't really matter that some things happen, when it's 80k, I expect everything to be perfect and stay that way at least 5 years.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top